Right Web

Tracking militarists’ efforts to influence U.S. foreign policy

Réalité-EU

Please note: IPS Right Web neither represents nor endorses any of the individuals or groups profiled on this site.

Réalité-EU is a UK-based policy group reportedly tied to the U.S. “Israel Lobby” that promotes aggressive European policies toward Iran and other extremist “threats” in the Middle East. The organization bills itself as “a resource centre for journalists, decision makers and analysts offering up-to-date analysis of issues pertaining to Iran's nuclear programme and support of terrorism.”[1] It was previously affiliated with the group International Media Intelligence Analysis, which dissolved in April 2009.[2]

The group’s preferred medium are “backgrounders,” which are posted to its website. These are overwhelmingly concerned with the activities of Iran and its allies. Subjects of interest include Iran’s human rights record, its relations with other countries, and its alleged nuclear weapons program. An August 2012 entry, for example, declared that the latest IAEA reports prove that “Iran has no intention to accede to the demands of the United Nations (UN) regarding its nuclear program. … It is not a good sign for those who hope and work for a peaceful resolution of the issue.”[3] Another entry from February 2012 concluded that “Iran is gradually moving closer to a nuclear capability,” suggesting that the time for a “non-violent resolution” to the Iranian nuclear saga was “growing shorter by the minute.”[4]

The Réalité-EU website also features a number of longer analytical and opinion pieces called “insights,” which cover much of the same ground as the backgrounders. In various entries, the group’s scholars call for sanctions on Iran, declare the unacceptability of a nuclear Iran, and raise alarms about Iran’s diplomatic and economic outreach in places like Latin America.[5]

The organization lists nine “expert sources” on its website. The list includes Kuwaiti government adviser Sami Alfaraj, former U.S. disarmament official Mark Fitzpatrick, Colombian security consultant Roman Ortiz, and Lebanese-born writer George Chaya, as well as several European-based scholars, including Bruno Tetrais, Frédéric Encel, Claude Moniquet, Matthias Küntzel, Victor Mizin, Emanuelle Vesely, and Kate Henriques.[6]

“Israel Lobby” Links

Réalité EU appears to be linked to the U.S. “Israel Lobby.” In 2010 and 2011, investigations by the progressive blogs LobeLog and Think Progress reported on evidence suggesting that Réalité-EU was linked with the U.S.-based Israel Project, a neoconservative-leaning, “pro-Israel” lobbying group led by AIPAC veteran Josh Block and “advised” by a host of legislators, including Sens. Joe Lieberman and Mark Kirk.

In July 2011, Think Progress discovered that Réalité-EU had received a $250,000 grant from the Marcus Foundation that was funneled through TIP. When queried by the blog’s reporters, a spokesperson for the supposedly London-based Réalité-EU turned out to be based in Washington and refused to say whether she worked out of the TIP office. A receptionist at TIP gave mixed responses to further queries.[7]

Although both groups emphasize the alleged Iranian nuclear threat, TIP focuses more explicitly on Israel while, according to Think Progress, “Réalité-EU has never presented itself as a pro-Israel organization or publicly associated with pro-Israel organizations like TIP.” Former TIP president Jennifer Laszlo Mizrahi has reportedly donated some $25,000 to the neoconservative Foundation for Defense of Democracies, whose scholars have advocated a number of hawkish U.S. policies toward Iran.[8]

Earlier, in January 2011, LobeLog reported that the Réalité-EU domain name had been registered by Mizrahi under the auspices of TIP, and that the two groups seemed to share server space and even a voice mailbox. Although the organization’s website provided UK phone and fax numbers as of mid-2012, during his 2011 investigation journalist Eli Clifton could find no record of Réalité-EU being registered as a legal entity in the UK, where it is supposedly based. He concluded that “there is strikingly little evidence to suggest that Réalité has much of a connection to London or Europe, where it seeks to inform European policymakers and journalists about ‘developments in and around the Middle East which pose a threat to Europe and beyond.’” Clifton suggested that Réalité-EU’s undisclosed ties to TIP raise questions about “whose interests the organization is representing.”[9]

As of the fall of 2012, Réalité-EU’s website no longer listed a contact address, although it did provide a UK phone number.

Track Record

Réalité EU gained widespread attention in mid-2007 when it published a “backgrounder” entitled “Ahmadinejad in His Own Words,” a compilation of inflammatory and outrageous statements made by the Iranian president. Reposted on a number of rightist websites like TownHall.com, the backgrounder cited quotes from Ahmadinejad including: "We don't shy away from declaring that Islam is ready to rule the world”; "Our revolution's main mission is to pave the way for the reappearance of the Twelfth Imam, the Mahdi"; “Soon Islam will become the dominating force in the world, occupying first place in the number of followers amongst all other religions”; and “Is there a craft more beautiful, more sublime, more divine, than the craft of giving yourself to martyrdom and becoming holy? Do not doubt, Allah will prevail, and Islam will conquer mountain tops of the entire world.”[10]

According to the document, Réalité EU complied the quotations to pressure the European Parliament ahead of a conference on Iran: “In light of the conference on Iran taking place in the European Parliament on Wednesday July 4 2007 the following quotes by The Islamic Republic of Iran’s President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad may be of interest,” it read. It bid readers to visit Réalité EU’s website for “further information about Iran’s well documented human rights abuses, its role as a major state sponsor of terrorism and its defiant stance on the international community’s insistence that the nation suspends its uranium enrichment program.”[11]

On May 9, 2007, Réalité EU organized a conference in Vienna called “Who’s Fueling Who?” in response to a planned Austria-Iran natural gas deal. Matthias Küntzel presented a paper entitled “Has Austria Accepted the Mullah’s Bomb?” in which he expressed outrage over the deal and concern over the consequences. “Austria seems to have fallen prey to the illusion that a nuclear Iran would have no impact on Europe. But there could be no bigger mistake. An Iran with nuclear weapons would be a nightmare not only for Israel, but also for Europe itself,” Küntzel wrote. “If Iran were to develop nuclear weapons, the whole of the Middle East would go nuclear too."[12]

Küntzel added, “The specific danger presented by the Iranian bomb, however, stems from the unique ideological atmosphere in which it would come into being: a mixture of death-wish and weapons-grade uranium, of Holocaust denial and High-Tech, of fantasies of world domination and missile research, of Shiite messianism and plutonium. There are other dictatorships in the world. But in Iran the fantasy-worlds of antisemitism and a sense of religious mission are combined with technological megalomania and the physics of mass destruction. Today, we again face a danger that first appeared on the horizon 70 years ago: the danger of a kind of ‘Adolf Hitler’ with nuclear weapons.”[13]

Also in May 2007, Claude Moniquet presented an analysis to a meeting at the London House of Commons entitled “Iranian Sponsored Terrorism in Europe.” In it, he asked whether there is “any real threat of a wave of terrorist attacks sponsored by Iran, in Europe or in the United States, if a military operation is decided to solve the problem of the Iranian nuclear program?” The answer, he concluded, is yes.[14]

According to the Associated Press: "‘We have serious signals that something is under preparation in Europe,’ Moniquet said, though he did not present any evidence to the meeting. ‘Iranian intelligence is working extremely hard to prepare its people and to prepare actions.’ … Iran appeared to be preparing to target ‘British citizens on the streets of London, just as they kill British soldiers in the south of Iraq,’ Moniquet said.”[15]

In October 2007, Réalité EU published a feature analysis from Peter Zimmerman, a professor of science and security studies at King’s College London who previously served as the chief scientist of the U.S. Senate Committee on Foreign Relations. Titled “Change Tack on Iran,” the piece highlighted the many ways by which Tehran had stifled investigation into its nuclear fuels program, though it cautioned against abandoning the diplomatic track. Zimmerman concluded: “American hawks and neocons are reputedly putting pressure on the Bush administration to talk tougher and to plan military strikes. While the military option must remain on the horizon, it would be an error to make the threat explicit right now. The advances in Iran’s nuclear programme mean that vigorous diplomacy backed by credible sanctions must aim at removing the completed centrifuges. This will buy some time, and sometimes delay is equivalent to denial, especially if it allows time for the Islamic Republic to abandon its nuclear programme and its hostility to its neighbours.”[16]

Share RightWeb

Please note: IPS Right Web neither represents nor endorses any of the individuals or groups profiled on this site.

Sources

[1] Réalité EU, http://www.realite-eu.org/.

[2]  Eli Clifton, “Is Réalité-EU Part Of The Israel Project?” LobeLog, January 20, 2011, http://www.lobelog.com/is-realite-eu-part-of-the-israel-project/.

[3] Bruno Tertrais, “Iran’s continued defiance: The new IAEA report in context,” Réalité-EU, August 31, 2012,http://www.realite-eu.org/site/apps/nlnet/content3.aspx?c=9dJBLLNkGiF&b=2315291&ct=12157545.

[4] Bruno Tertrais, “What does Iran want?” Réalité-EU, February 28, 2012, http://www.realite-eu.org/site/apps/nlnet/content3.aspx?c=9dJBLLNkGiF&b=2315291&ct=11637327

[5] Réalité-EU, “Insights,” http://www.realite-eu.org/site/c.9dJBLLNkGiF/b.2300349/k.D909/Insights/apps/nl/newsletter3.asp.

[6] Réalité-EU, “Expert Sources,” http://www.realite-eu.org/site/c.9dJBLLNkGiF/b.2268653/k.AA99/Expert_Sources.htm.

[7] Eli Clifton and Ali Gharib, “EXCLUSIVE: The Israel Project Covers Up Ties With Iran-Focused Media Organization ‘Réalité-EU,’” Think Progress, July 20, 2011, http://thinkprogress.org/security/2011/07/20/270650/israel-project-realite-eu/.

[8] Eli Clifton and Ali Gharib, “EXCLUSIVE: The Israel Project Covers Up Ties With Iran-Focused Media Organization ‘Réalité-EU,’” Think Progress, July 20, 2011, http://thinkprogress.org/security/2011/07/20/270650/israel-project-realite-eu/.

[9] Eli Clifton, “Is Réalité-EU Part Of The Israel Project?” LobeLog, January 20, 2011, http://www.lobelog.com/is-realite-eu-part-of-the-israel-project/.

[10] Réalité-EU, “Ahmadinejad in His Own Words,” http://www.realite-eu.org/site/apps/nl/content3.asp?c=9dJBLLNkGiF&b=2315291&ct=4058419.

[11] Réalité-EU, “Ahmadinejad in His Own Words,” http://www.realite-eu.org/site/apps/nl/content3.asp?c=9dJBLLNkGiF&b=2315291&ct=4058419.

[12] Matthias Küntzel, “Has Austria Accepted the Mullah’s Bomb?” Réalité-EU Conference, “Who’s Fueling Who?” May 9, 2007.

[13] Matthias Küntzel, “Has Austria Accepted the Mullah’s Bomb?” Réalité-EU Conference, “Who’s Fueling Who?” May 9, 2007.

[14] Claude Moniquet, “Iranian Sponsored Terrorism in Europe,” Presentation to House of Commons, May 22, 2007,http://www.realite-eu.org/site/c.9dJBLLNkGiF/b.2294703/apps/nl/content3.asp?content_id=&notoc=1

[15] Claude Moniquet, “Iranian Sponsored Terrorism in Europe,” Presentation to House of Commons, May 22, 2007,http://www.realite-eu.org/site/c.9dJBLLNkGiF/b.2294703/apps/nl/content3.asp?content_id=&notoc=1

[16] Peter Zimmerman, “Change Tack on Iran,” October 17, 2007, http://www.realite-eu.org/site/c.9dJBLLNkGiF/b.3444277/k.8772/Change_Tack_on_Nuclear_Iran.htm.

Share RightWeb

Réalité-EU Résumé

Contact Information

Réalité-EU
Phone: +44 203 286 0091
E-mail: info@realite-eu.org
Website: http://www.realite-eu.org/
 

Réalité-EU News Feed

Diplomats: EU Wrestling With Iran Nuclear Deal After American Exit - USNI NewsThe Switch Version Of Dragon Quest XI Has A Special Name - Nintendo LifeSoapbox: Why A Nintendo 64 Classic Edition Might Not Be Such A Good Idea - Nintendo LifeMasahiro Sakurai On The Smash Bros. Character Decision Process And Piranha Plant's Surprise Inclusion - Nintendo LifeGaming Analysts Predict 'Switch Pro' And 'Switch Lite' Revisions For 2019 - Nintendo LifeWahoo KICKR CORE Trainer In-Depth Review - DC RainmakerGallery: Super Smash Bros. Ultimate Full Character Roster (Final List Updated) - Nintendo LifeTwo Limited Edition Pokémon Let's Go Switch Consoles Arrive This November - Nintendo LifeMonster Hunter Generations Ultimate Hits Switch This August - Nintendo LifeUK Charts: Super Smash Bros. Ultimate Becomes The Fastest-Selling Smash Game Of All Time - Nintendo LifeVideo: The Pokémon Detective Pikachu Movie's First Official Trailer Has Landed - Nintendo LifeExplainer: What will the new Airbnb laws mean for homeowners and landlords? - TheJournal.ieThe New Polar Vantage Series: Everything you ever wanted to know - DC RainmakerNew Surface Forces Instruction Restricts Who Can Earn a SWO Pin - USNI NewsLeaked Magazine Scan Confirms Jiren Is Joining The Battle In Dragon Ball FighterZ - Nintendo LifeFeature: Digital vs Physical - What Is Your Preference for Nintendo Switch? - Nintendo LifeFeature: SNES Classic Edition Vs. PlayStation Classic - Which One Should You Choose? - Nintendo LifeThe Physics of why the e-Cat's Cold Fusion Claims Collapse - ScienceBlogsStarlink: Battle for Atlas Review (Switch) - Nintendo LifeFeature: Our 15 Most Anticipated Nintendo Switch Games of 2019 - Nintendo Life

Right Web is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

The Right Web Mission

Right Web tracks militarists’ efforts to influence U.S. foreign policy.

For media inquiries,
email rightwebproject@gmail.com

From the Wires

François Nicoullaud, the former French ambassador to Iran, discusses the ups and downs of Iran-France relations and the new US sanctions.


Effective alliances require that powerful states shoulder a far larger share of the alliance maintenance costs than other states, a premise that Donald Trump rejects.


The new imbroglio over the INF treaty does not mean a revival of the old Cold War practice of nuclear deterrence. However, it does reveal the inability of the West and Russia to find a way to deal with the latter’s inevitable return to the ranks of major powers, a need that was obvious even at the time the USSR collapsed.


As a presidential candidate, Donald Trump appeared to recognize the obvious problem of the revolving door. But as the appointment of Patrick Shanahan, who spent 30 years at Boeing, as the Trump administration’s acting secretary of defense reveals, little has changed. America is indeed great again, if you happen to be one of those lucky enough to be moving back and forth between plum jobs in the Pentagon and the weapons industry.


Domestic troubles, declining popularity, and a decidedly hawkish anti-Iran foreign policy team may combine to make the perfect storm that pushes Donald Trump to pull the United States into a new war in the Middle East.


The same calculus that brought Iran and world powers to make a deal and has led remaining JCPOA signatories to preserve it without the U.S. still holds: the alternatives to this agreement – a race between sanctions and centrifuges that could culminate in Iran obtaining the bomb or being bombed – would be much worse.


With Bolton and Pompeo by his side and Mattis departed, Trump may well go with his gut and attack Iran militarily. He’ll be encouraged in this delusion by Israel and Saudi Arabia. He’ll of course be looking for some way to distract the media and the American public. And he won’t care about the consequences.


RightWeb
share