Right Web

Tracking militarists’ efforts to influence U.S. foreign policy

Herman Cain

  • 2012 GOP Presidential Candidate
  • Godfather’s Pizza: Former CEO

Please note: IPS Right Web neither represents nor endorses any of the individuals or groups profiled on this site.

Herman Cain is a former CEO of the Omaha, Nebraska-based Godfather’s Pizza chain, as well as a former talk radio host, columnist, and chairman of the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City. During a brief spell in 2011, Cain was a leading candidate along with former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney and Rick Perry for the 2012 Republican presidential nomination.[1] Among his foreign policy advisers were several former aids to leading Republican hawks like Donald Rumsfeld and Rep. Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, including J.D. Gordon, an ersthwile fellow at the neoconservative Center for Security Policy and former Pentagon public affairs officer.

Cain centered his campaign on his business experience, his so-called “9-9-9” flat tax plan, and his folksy, “un-politician” demeanor. He often struggled, however, to articulate foreign policy positions and has, on occasion, demonstrated a certain contempt for such concerns. In a now-famous appearance on the Christian Broadcasting Network, an interviewer asked Cain whether he was “ready for the ‘gotcha’ questions that are coming from the media and others on foreign policy […] Like, who’s the president of Uzbekistan?” Badly bungling the word “Uzbekistan,” Cain replied, “[W]hen they ask me who is the president of Ubeki-beki-beki-beki-stan-stan, I’m going to say … how’s that going to create one job?” He added, “Knowing who is the head of some of these small insignificant states around the world—I don’t think that is something that is critical to focusing on national security and getting this economy going.”

Observers pointed out that Uzbekistan’s authoritarian president Islam Karimov, though a ruthless dictator, provided important logistical support to the U.S. mission in Afghanistan, making him hardly immaterial to U.S. foreign policy.[2] After that incident, Cain's staff reportedly given him a list of 20 world leaders to commit to memory.

On other occasions, Cain demonstrated uncertainty and ignorance about broader foreign policy questions. When asked by Fox News’ Chris Wallace in May 2011 whether he supported a right of return for Palestinian refugees from Israel, Cain replied, “That’s something that should be negotiated. … I don’t think they have a big problem with people returning.”[3] When numerous blogs pointed out this departure from the “pro-Likud script,” his campaign reversed course, issuing a statement that said, “[I]s the ‘right of return’ a moral imperative? Is it something Israel must grant? Is it something the United States ought to encourage? The answer is no on every count.”[4] In other instances, Cain has wrongly attributed the Bush-negotiated Iraq drawdown to President Obama[5] and incorrectly insisted that the United States currently officially recognizes the government of Taiwan.[6]

In what he dubs the “Cain Doctrine,” Cain described his foreign policy as “an extension of the Reagan philosophy. … My philosophy is peace through strength and clarity. We need to clarify who our friends are, clarify who our enemies are, stop giving money to the enemies, and make sure that our enemies know who our friends are, that we are going to stand solidly behind.”[7] Elsewhere, in his autobiography This Is Herman Cain!, Cain summed up the doctrine slightly differently, writing, “I can tell you what the Cain Doctrine would be: if you mess with Israel, you're messing with the United States of America. Is that clear?”[8]

Cain often demurred on more complicated foreign policy questions, particularly with regard to Iran, Afghanistan, and the broader Middle East, promising instead to consult with unnamed advisors. In a Meet the Press interview, for example, he limited his remarks on Afghanistan to a promise to listen to “the commanders on the ground.” He added, “A lot of analysis needs to go into determining whether or not there is a definition of victory in Afghanistan.”[9]

Still, he often sounded a hawkish note, telling Fox News contributor KT McFarland, “I don’t think we can stop [Iran] from getting a nuclear weapon without some sort of pre-emptive strike,” before adding, “I would have to talk to a lot of people before I would go so far as to say we should do a pre-emptive strike.”[10] Cain has threatened military action against Iran on other occasions as well. “Option A,” he said, “is, 'Folks, we are not going to allow [Iran] to attack Israel.’ If they call my bluff, they already know—they will know—what Option B is.” He called for placing U.S. weapons systems in the Persian Gulf, encouraging Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad to “make my day.”

In other hawish moments, Cain said he would give the Palestinians “nothing” in any potential peace deal with Israel, criticized President Obama’s “appeasement” of China, and called for an electrified “twenty-foot wall” along the U.S.-Mexico border, accompanied by a “moat” with “alligators.”[11]

Perhaps exceeding even the rest of the Republican field, Cain also made strikingly anti-Islamic statements and warned of “creeping sharia.” Echoing the admonitions of neoconservative Islamophobes like Frank Gaffney and David Yerushalmi, Cain warned that “some people would infuse Sharia law in our court system if we allow it."[12] Cain used the supposed threat of sharia to effectively ban Muslims from his cabinet[13] and to defend the right of local communities to prohibit the construction of mosques.[14] Though he later walked back these positions, he never disavowed his statements about Islam or sharia.[15]

When asked by host David Gregory on the Meet the Press if he would describe himself as a neoconservative, Cain replied that although he is “very conservative,” he was “not familiar with the neoconservative movement.” He did, however, list prominent neoconservatives John Bolton and KT McFarland among his most important foreign policy influences, along with the realist yet hawkish former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger. This led Think Progress to conclude, “Cain’s foreign policy seems to clearly lean into the neoconservative camp—whether or not he understands or admits it.”[16]

Because of Cain's inexperience in foreign policy, some observers endeavored to divine his views through the prism of his adviser J.D. Gordon, the former Pentagon aid whose lobbying firm has been linked to the Altantic Bridge influence-peddling scandal in the United Kingdom. On the basis of Gordon’s op-eds and Fox News appearances, one writer claimed that “Cain is getting the same national security advice he would from Dick Cheney. Gordon’s views are reflexively right-wing.” The Nation's Ben Adler opined, "[Gordon’s] views are not realist or idealist or subject to any such overarching approach or ideology. … Gordon’s views could broadly be called conservative and hawkish but they are more accurately described as Republican. If Obama does something, even kill a terrorist, it is ipso facto the wrong choice. … There are some things one can safely assume Gordon is telling Cain—for example, that torture of terrorist suspects is justified and effective. But since the entirety of Gordon’s policy assessment technique seems to be defending anything Bush did and attacking anything Obama does, it is impossible to guess how he or Cain would respond to future threats as they emerge. Looking at some of the belligerent extremists who have run for president as Republicans in recent times, such as John McCain and Rudy Giuliani, that uncertainty might seem comforting by comparison.”

Neoconservatives were skeptical of Cain's seriousness on foreign policy. Jonathan Tobin, editor of the neoconservative Commentary magazine, concluded that Cain “hasn’t done much to correct his lack of knowledge about war and peace issues which are, after all, a president’s first responsibility.” Referring to Cain’s Meet the Press appearance, Tobin added, “that someone running for that office has not even heard the term [neoconservative] suggests Cain is not only bereft of foreign policy experience, he apparently has never even read much about it.”[17] Max Boot, another Commentary contributor, commented similarly, “Being commander in chief is the most important role for any president, and Herman Cain just isn’t credible in that role.”[18]

Share RightWeb

Please note: IPS Right Web neither represents nor endorses any of the individuals or groups profiled on this site.


[1] David Nir, “Cain leading in seven straight PPP polls,” Daily Kos, October 19, 2011, http://www.dailykos.com/story/2011/10/19/1028022/-Cain-leading-in-seven-straight-PPP-polls

[2] Ali Gharib, “Herman Cain: I Don’t Know The ‘President Of Ubeki-beki-beki-stan-stan,’” Think Progress, October 9, 2011, http://thinkprogress.org/security/2011/10/09/339879/cain-uzbekistan-beki-beki-stan-stan/.

[3] Faiz Shakir, “GOP Contender Herman Cain Demonstrates Clueslessness On Middle East Policy, Confused By ‘Right Of Return,” Think Progress, May 22, 2011, http://thinkprogress.org/security/2011/05/22/168582/herman-cain-right-of-return/.

[4] Marie Diamond, “Herman Cain Backtracks, Tries To Salvage Botched ‘Right Of Return’ Answer,” Think Progress, May 23, 2011, http://thinkprogress.org/politics/2011/05/23/168651/cain-right-of-return-reversal/.

[5] Ali Gharib, “Herman Cain Blames Obama For Bush’s Iraq Withdrawal Deadline,” Think Progress, October 16, 2011, http://thinkprogress.org/security/2011/10/16/345165/herman-cain-blames-obama-for-bushs-iraq-withdrawal-deadline/.

[6] Scott Keyes, “Herman Cain’s Latest Foreign Policy Gaffe: ‘We Already Recognize’ The Government Of Taiwan,” Think Progress, July 12, 2011, http://thinkprogress.org/security/2011/07/12/266582/cain-foreign-policy-gaffe-we-recognize-taiwan/.

[7] Jordan Helton, “Herman Cain's foreign policy: 5 things to know,” Global Post, October 18, 2011, http://www.globalpost.com/dispatch/news/regions/americas/united-states/111018/herman-cain-foreign-policy

[8] Daniel Drezner, “This is Herman Cain's Foreign Policy!” Foreign Policy, October 16, 2011, http://drezner.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2011/10/15/this_is_herman_cains_foreign_policy.

[9] Jordan Helton, “Herman Cain's foreign policy: 5 things to know,” Global Post, October 18, 2011, http://www.globalpost.com/dispatch/news/regions/americas/united-states/111018/herman-cain-foreign-policy.

[10] Alexander Burns, “Cain tells McFarland: Only preemptive strike can stop Iran,” Politico, October 17, 2011, http://www.politico.com/news/stories/1011/66182.html#ixzz1bMiz6HvC.

[11] Joshua Keating, “Nobody's gonna make Herman Cain talk about foreign policy if he doesn't want to,” Foreign Policy, October 11, 2011, http://blog.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2011/10/11/nobodys_gonna_make_herman_cain_talk_about_foreign_policy_if_he_doesnt_want_to.

[12] Joshua Keating, “Nobody's gonna make Herman Cain talk about foreign policy if he doesn't want to,” Foreign Policy, October 11, 2011, http://blog.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2011/10/11/nobodys_gonna_make_herman_cain_talk_about_foreign_policy_if_he_doesnt_want_to.

[13] Scott Keyes, “Herman Cain Tells ThinkProgress ‘I Will Not’ Appoint A Muslim In My Administration,” Think Progress, March 26, 2011, http://thinkprogress.org/politics/2011/03/26/153625/herman-cain-muslims/.

[14] Evan McMorris-Santoro, “Herman Cain: American Communities Have The Right To Ban Mosques,” Talking Points Memo, July 17, 2011, http://tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com/2011/07/herman-cain-american-communities-have-the-right-to-ban-mosques.php.

[15] Evan McMorris-Santoro, “Herman Cain Apologizes to Muslims,” Talking Points Memo, July 27, 2011, http://tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com/2011/07/herman-cain-apologizes-to-muslims.php.

[16] Eli Clifton, “Herman Cain: ‘I’m Not Familiar With The Neoconservative Movement.’” Think Progress, October 16, 2011, http://thinkprogress.org/security/2011/10/16/345119/herman-cain-im-not-familiar-with-the-neoconservative-movement/.

[17] Jonathan Tobin, “Herman Cain Still Proudly Ignorant on Foreign Policy,” Commentary, October 16, 2011, http://www.commentarymagazine.com/2011/10/16/cain-foreign-policy-ignorance-neoconservatism/.

[18] Chris Cillizza, “Herman Cain’s know-nothing foreign policy (and why it matters),” The Washington Post, October 17, 2011, http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-fix/post/herman-cains-know-nothing-foreign-policy-and-why-it-matters/2011/10/17/gIQA4J8mrL_blog.html.

Share RightWeb

Herman Cain Résumé


  • Americans for Prosperity: Spokesman for “Prosperity Expansion Project” (2005-2006)
  • National Restaurant Association: Former CEO



  • Pillsbury Co.: Former CEO of Godfather’s Pizza, Vice President of Burger King
  • Aquila, Inc.: Former board member
  • Nabisco: Former board member
  • Whirpool: Former board member
  • Reader’s Digest: Former board member
  • AGCO: Former board member
  • Coca-Cola: Former systems analyst



  • Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City: Chairman (1995-1996), Deputy Chairman (1992-1994)
  • U.S. Navy: Former civilian ballistics analyst



  • Purdue University: MS
  • Morehouse College: BS


Herman Cain News Feed

Trump to Nominate Federal Reserve Board Critic Stephen Moore for a Seat on the Board - FortuneTrump considering Stephen Moore, Herman Cain for Fed board: report - MarketWatchHerman Cain column: Ten questions every Democrat presidential candidate needs to answer - Savannah Morning NewsElizabeth Warren's plan to regulate big tech is 'anti-capitalistic' and 'anti-competitive': Herman Cain - Fox BusinessHerman Cain on Fox Business: Sen. Elizabeth Warren's proposal to break up big tech companies would fit in with Venezuela or Cuba - Media Matters for AmericaFrom The Godfather pizzas to the Federal Reserve - The Corner EconomicThe great political parachute - AxiosTrump Considering Herman Cain for Federal Reserve Board, Sources Say - BloombergHerman Cain Says He Would Be Honored to Be Considered for Fed Job - Wall Street JournalHerman Cain Is on a Thin Crust - Wall Street JournalHerman Cain's monetary heresies aren't as crazy as they sound | TheHill - The Hill5 things to know about Herman Cain - Atlanta Journal ConstitutionTrump Considering Herman Cain for Federal Reserve Board: Report - The Daily BeastHerman Cain launches super PAC to support President Trump's agenda | TheHill - The HillHerman Cain: The Trump economy is stronger than you may think - Des Moines RegisterExclusive: Herman Cain's WSB show ending August 3 - Atlanta Journal ConstitutionHerman Cain reappears in support of Diehl’s ‘long shot’ bid [+audio] - Boston HeraldHerman Cain column: Abrams sabotaged own campaign with extreme agenda - Savannah Morning NewsHerman Cain touts opportunity zones; gets heckled - PE HubHerman Cain: Dems Sound Like an Out-of-Tune Orchestra Playing the 'Hate Trump' Symphony - Fox News Insider

Right Web is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

The Right Web Mission

Right Web tracks militarists’ efforts to influence U.S. foreign policy.

For media inquiries,
email rightwebproject@gmail.com

Featured Profiles

Donald Trump’s second attorney general, William Barr is the focus of a growing controversy over the Robert Mueller report because his decision to unilaterally declare that the the president had not obstructed justice during the Mueller investigation.

The American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), one of the more effective U.S. lobbying outfits, aims to ensure that the United States backs Israel regardless of the policies Israel pursues.

Erik Prince, former CEO of the mercenary group Blackwater, continues to sell security services around the world as controversies over his work—including in China and the Middle East, and his alleged involvement in collusion between the Trump campaign and Russia—grow.

Gina Haspel is the first woman to hold the position of director of the CIA, winning her confirmation despite her history of involvement in torture during the Iraq War.

Democratic Majority for Israel (DMFI) is a pressure group founded in early 2019 that serves as a watchdog and enforcer of Israel’s reputation in the Democratic Party.

Richard Grenell is the U.S. ambassador to Germany for the Donald Trump administration, known for his brusque and confrontational style.

Zalmay Khalilzad is Donald Trump’s special representative to the Afghan peace process, having previously served as ambassador to Afghanistan and Iraq under George W. Bush.