Right Web

Tracking militarists’ efforts to influence U.S. foreign policy

Forgotten American Coalition

Please note: IPS Right Web neither represents nor endorses any of the individuals or groups profiled on this site.

The Forgotten American Coalition (FAC) was a short-lived letterhead group founded in 2007 to rally religious conservatives against U.S. withdrawal from Iraq. Chaired by longtime Christian conservative activist Gary Bauer, the group’s membership included a few dozen social conservatives and religious right activists, alongside a handful of prominent neoconservatives and hardline nationalists. Some of the coalition's more notable members included Frank Gaffneyof the Center for Security Policy, Daniel Pipesof the Middle East Forum, Clifford Mayof the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, Herb Zweibon of Americans for a Safe Israel, Pat Robertson of the 700 Club, John Hagee of Citizens United for Israel, Heritage Foundation cofounder Paul Weyrich, and the writer Mona Charen.[1]

Echoing President Richard Nixon's appeals to a "silent majority"—which he claimed supported the war in Vietnam and opposed the antiwar movement—Bauer pitched the group as a response to "the defeatism of America’s leftist elites." In a blog post promoting the new coalition, Bauer claimed that "while the anti-war Left makes all the noise, the silent majority embraces a more reasoned approach."[2] The group's name appears to be a reference to Barry Goldwater's own "Forgotten American coalition"—a predecessor of Nixon's "Southern strategy" to lure segregationist whites into the Republican fold.[3]

FAC main advocacy initiative involved publishing a September 2007 open letter speaking out against a U.S. withdrawal from Iraq. Published as General David Petraeus went before Congress to testify about the deeply unpopular war, the letter echoed both Bush administration talking points and "clash of civilizations" rhetoric about the stakes of the war. "The Iraq War must be seen in the broader context of Islamo-fascism's war on America and Western Civilization," the letter claimed. "It is one front in a global conflict fought from Europe and the Middle East to Africa, the Balkans, the Indian Subcontinent and, finally, to the streets of our cities." Although Iraq's link to the 9/11 terrorist attacks had long been discredited, the letter warned that withdrawal would precipitate similar attacks in the future. "9/11 was in part precipitated by the perception of American weakness and lack of determination," it insisted. "An Iraq withdrawal before our mission is accomplished will convince the terrorists and their state-sponsors that we indeed are the proverbial paper tiger." The letter closed by warning that withdrawal would empower the "isolationist left," leaving "the surrender lobby in charge of U.S. foreign policy for the foreseeable future."[4]

The message was specifically tailored for social conservatives. "Historically, values organizations have been reluctant to engage in foreign policy," Bauer wrote in his blog post. "But six years into a struggle that has reshaped understandings of the relationship between war and duty, our unique coalition reaffirms a fundamental insight: Victory is a values issue. We believe defeat at the hands of an ideology that worships death would be immoral."[5] Don Feder, a member of FAC's 10-person steering committee, echoed this sentiment in the group's press release: "By signing this declaration, religious conservatives are saying: 'Yes, we care about marriage, the family, and the unborn,'" he said. "'But we also care about national security, the morale of our servicemen and women, and the war on terrorism.' The left, which thinks neo-cons are the only ones on the right opposing an Iraq withdrawal, had better think again."[6]

Despite the group's appeals to "silent" and "forgotten" majorities, critics charged that the group was just another conduit for beltway talking points. Fred Clarkson, co-founder of the blog TalkToAction, told the Inter Press Service that the coalition appeared to be "a classic inside the beltway paper tiger. It doesn't exist," he explained, "except to issue 'messages' to true believers and to make it appear in the media that there is more support for a failed foreign policy than really exists."[7]

The group—which has no website or publicly available tax documents—does not appear to have been active after 2007. 

Share RightWeb

Please note: IPS Right Web neither represents nor endorses any of the individuals or groups profiled on this site.

Sources

[1] Bill Berkowitz, "Far Right Sells Iraq War to 'Values Voters,'" Inter Press Service, September 21, 2007, http://www.ipsnews.net/2007/09/politics-us-far-right-sells-iraq-war-to-quotvalues-votersquot/.

[2] Gary Bauer, "Victory Is a Values Issue," Human Events, September 14, 2007, http://www.humanevents.com/2007/09/14/victory-is-a-values-issue/.

[3] See Jason Morgan Ward, Defending White Democracy: The Remaking of a Segregationist Movement & the Remaking of Racial Politics, 1936-1965 (University of North Carolina Press, 2011), p. 170, http://books.google.com/books?id=bG7mRv1lDWQC&pg=PA170&dq=%22Forgotten+American+Coalition%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=KNZCU4OEEebisAS_qYAo&ved=0CC0Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=%22Forgotten%20American%20Coalition%22&f=false.

[4] Forgotten American Coalition, “Values Votes Leaders Sign Declaration against Iraq Withdrawal,” PR Newswire, September 10, 2007, http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/values-vote-leaders-sign-declaration-against-iraq-withdrawal-57943002.html.

[5] Gary Bauer, "Victory Is a Values Issue," Human Events, September 14, 2007, http://www.humanevents.com/2007/09/14/victory-is-a-values-issue/.

[6] Forgotten American Coalition, “Values Votes Leaders Sign Declaration against Iraq Withdrawal,” PR Newswire, September 10, 2007, http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/values-vote-leaders-sign-declaration-against-iraq-withdrawal-57943002.html.

[7] Bill Berkowitz, "Far Right Sells Iraq War to 'Values Voters,'" Inter Press Service, September 21, 2007, http://www.ipsnews.net/2007/09/politics-us-far-right-sells-iraq-war-to-quotvalues-votersquot/.

Share RightWeb

Forgotten American Coalition Résumé

Founded

2007


Members

  • Gary Bauer (Chairman, Forgotten American Coalition)
  • Joe Barrek
  • Chris Carmouche (GrassTopsUSA.com)
  • Don Feder (Don Feder Associates)
  • Janet Folger (Faith2Action)
  • Richard Ford (Heritage Alliance PAC)
  • Rick Scarborough (Vision America)
  • Mike Valerio
  • Paul Weyrich (Free Congress Foundation)
  • Don Wildmon (American Family Association)
  • Daniel Pipes (Middle East Forum)
  • Pat Robertson ("700 Club")
  • Phillip Jauregui (Judicial Action Group)
  • Phil Burress (Citizens for Community Values)
  • William J. Federer (AmeriSearch)
  • Wendy Wright (Concerned Women for America)
  • Dr. Janice Crouse (Beverly LaHaye Institute)
  • Dr. Jack Wheeler (Freedom Research Foundation)
  • Rabbi Daniel Lapin (Toward Tradition)
  • Frank Gaffney (Center for Security Policy)
  • Herb Zweibon (Americans for a Safe Israel)
  • Lou Sheldon (Traditional Values Coalition)
  • Mona Charen (syndicated columnist)
  • Morton Blackwell (Conservative Leadership PAC)
  • Gary Cass (Christian Anti-Defamation Commission)
  • Pastor John Hagee (Citizens United for Israel)
  • Larry Cirignano (Catholic activist)
  • Star Parker (Coalition on Urban Renewal and Education)
  • Clifford May (Foundation for the Defense of Democracies)
  • Jim Laffejy (Christian Seniors Association)
  • Michael Heath (Christian Civic League of Maine)
  • Ted Baehr (MovieGuide.org)
  • Mathew Staver (Liberty Counsel)
  • Colin Hanna (Let Freedom Ring)
  • Craig Shirley (Shirley and Bannister Public Affairs)
  • Ron Wexler (Ten Commandments Commission)
  • Foster Friess (Friess Associates Inc.)
  • Tim LaHaye (minister and author)
  • Beverly LaHaye (Concerned Women for America)
  • Dr. Rod Majin (The Vanguard.Org)
  • Melanie Morgan (MoveAmericaForward.org)
  • Elaine Donnelly (Center for Military Readiness)
  • Ron Robinson (Young America's Foundation)
  • Flagg Youngblood (Young America's Foundation)

Related:

Forgotten American Coalition News Feed

A Forgotten Italian Port Could Become a Chinese Gateway to Europe - The New York TimesDoes affirmative action help or hurt Asians who don't fit the model-minority stereotype? - The Washington PostHmong students are among the forgotten minorities of higher education - Alton TelegraphThis app uses augmented reality to rewrite 'herstory' - World Economic ForumRemarks by Vice President Pence at The Latino Coalition Legislative Summit - Whitehouse.govHow A Long-Forgotten Act Of Police Brutality Transformed A Federal Judge, U.S. President And Civil Rights In America - WBURPEN America to Honor Trailblazing Truthteller Anita Hill with 2019 PEN Courage Award - PEN AmericaTrump’s 2020 strategy: Politicize Israel, demonize Ilhan Omar and keep voters at home - Haaretz'Women never to be forgotten' | Columns | Journal Gazette - Fort Wayne Journal GazetteRemarks by Vice President Pence at CPAC 2019 | National Harbor, MD - Whitehouse.govProfessor Laura Weinrib to Lecture on the "Weaponization" of the First Amendment - CU Boulder TodayPuerto Ricans push presidential candidates to make island a top campaign issue - NBCNews.comMeet The Lagoon's Forgotten Lady And See 'The Strangest Movie Never Made' - WEAAMURDERED & MISSING but not forgotten - AlleynewsUS faith groups unite to decry Beijing’s crackdown on religion - South China Morning PostBernie Sanders' opening argument: I am electable. Really. - WCVB BostonBehind Willie Wilson's appeal to black voters: 'Willie’s story is the story of black people in America and black people in Chicago.' - Chicago TribuneFlag raised in honor of trailblazing African-American colonel - WLKY LouisvilleHow income inequality affects our mental health - Financial TimesAIPAC ignores Netanyahu's racism - The Electronic Intifada

Right Web is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

The Right Web Mission

Right Web tracks militarists’ efforts to influence U.S. foreign policy.

For media inquiries,
email rightwebproject@gmail.com

From the Wires

The Senate on Wednesday passed a measure mandating the withdrawal of U.S. forces from the Saudi/UAE-led war against Houthi rebels in Yemen. The vote marks the first time since the War Powers Act of 1973 became law that both chambers of Congress have directed the president to withdraw American forces from a conflict.


The Trump administration’s failed “maximum pressure” approach to Iran and North Korea begs the question what the US president’s true objectives are and what options he is left with should the policy ultimately fail.


In the United States, it’s possible to debate any and every policy, domestic and foreign, except for unquestioning support for Israel. That, apparently, is Ilhan Omar’s chief sin.


While Michael Cohen mesmerized the House of Representatives and President Trump resumed his love affair with North Korea’s Kim Jong, one of the most dangerous state-to-state confrontations, centering in Kashmir, began to spiral out of control.


The Trump administration’s irresponsible withdrawal from the landmark Iran nuclear agreement undermined Iran’s Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif and emboldened hardliners who accused him of having been deceived by Washington while negotiating the agreement. However, the Iranian government could use the shock of Zarif’s resignation to push back against hardliners and take charge of both the domestic and foreign affairs of the country while Iran’s foreign opponents should consider the risks of destabilizing the government under the current critical situation.


Europe can play an important role in rebuilding confidence in the non-proliferation regime in the wake of the demise of the INF treaty, including by making it clear to the Trump administration that it wants the United States to refrain from deploying INF-banned missiles in Europe and to consider a NATO-Russian joint declaration on non-first deployment.


The decline in Israel’s appeal to Democrats is directly related to the wider awareness of the country’s increasingly authoritarian nature, its treatment of Palestinians, and its reluctance to take substantive steps toward peace. Pro-Israel liberals face a fundamental paradox trying to reconcile Israel’s illiberalism with their political values.


RightWeb
share