Right Web

Tracking militarists’ efforts to influence U.S. foreign policy

Council on Foreign Relations

Council on Foreign Relations

Acronym/Code: COFR

Updated: 9/89

Categories:Political

Background: The Council on Foreign Relations (COFR) was established in 1921. It is a nonprofit, nonpartisan membership organization with a current membership of 2,450. Membership is by invitation only through nomination by the membership committee and approval by the board of directors. (1) The Council takes no institutional position on foreign policy issues and no one is authorized to speak on behalf of the Council. (1) The Council has 38 independent branches around the U.S., and provides the majority of speakers for their meetings. (1)

The Council’s library is open to "qualified" members of the public; its quarterly journal, Foreign Affairs is available to the public. (1)

There was a struggle for power in the Council over who was to succeed David Rockefeller who retired in 1985. It appears that struggle was between the forces of former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger and former Secretary of State Cyrus Vance. (5,6) Peter G. Peterson who emerged as chairman is a close associate of Henry Kissinger. (5,6) Peter Tarnoff, the Vance candidate for the chair, became the Council’s president. (6) It was suggested by one Council source that a Peterson victory could turn the COFR into "a shadow Bush cabinet."(5)

The Council on Foreign Relations attempts to influence official U.S. policy, and a number of its members have a history of working closely with the CIA. (4)

Funding: The Council on Foreign Relations receives no funding from the U.S. or any other government. (1)

A portion of its funding comes from dues which range from a low of $60 for non-resident, non-business members under 30 years of age to $1,200 for resident business members over 40 years of age. (1) In 1987, the Council received individual contributions of over $500,000 from 1,237 individuals. (1) The bulk of the Council’s funding comes from corporate contributions. In 1987, the Council received over $4,316,000 in new endowments, grants and gifts, and an additional $640,000 in installment payments on multi-year grants. (1) Additionally, it has a pledge campaign which brought in more than $1. 5 million. (1)

Over the years major donors have included the Ford Fdn which gave $300,000 in 1985 and 1986, the Wm and Flora Hewlett Fdn which donated $300,000 in 1986, the Dillon Fund with a donation of $250,000 in 1986, and the Carnegie Fdn with a grant of $150,000 in 1986. Other donors in those years included ARCO Fdn, General Electric Fdn, Ford Motor Company Fdn, Bank America Fdn, American Can Co Fdn, Cummins Engine Fdn, Texaco Fdn, Phillips Petroleum Fdn, Morgan Guarantee Trust Fdn, Corning Glass Works Fdn, AT&T, the Florence and John Schumann Fdn, the General Motors Fdn, the Rockefeller Fdn, the Alfred P. Sloan Fdn, and Proctor & Gamble. (2,3)

Contributions from corporations and other organizations in 1987 included most of those mentioned above and also included The Asia Fdn, Association of Radio and Television News Analysts, Bristol-Myers Co, The German Marshall Fund, IBM World Trade Corp, Andrew Mellon Fdn, Rockefeller Brothers Fund, The Smith Richardson Fdn, the Starr Fdn, and the Xerox Fdn. (1)

In 1987, Thomas J. Watson, Jr. and Helen W. Buckner gave a $2 millon grant to COFR. Xerox Corp gave $750,000 in honor of its retiring chairman, C. Peter McColough, who was treasurer of COFR for nine years. Rita Hauser made a $300,000 grant for a studies program on regional security issues. (1)

The Council’s investment portfolio had a value of $47. 3 million on June 30, 1988. (1)

Activities: The activities of the Council on Foreign Relations consist primarily of seminars, conferences, and study sessions. (1) In 1987, COFR Meetings Program held 153 meetings in the Harold Pratt House, 6 regionally in the U.S. and 2 in Europe. (1) Speakers at the meetings included 15 heads of state and 15 foreign ministers. (1)

In the same year, COFR held 67 meetings and 13 study sessions in Washington. Ambassadors Robert Strauss and Philip Habib helped the Council establish a Middle East Forum that offered 12 programs and included a meeting with Secretary of State George Shultz. (1) Similarly, CIA director William Webster was the keynote speaker at COFR’s annual meeting for members and their families. (1)

In other words, the COFR has meetings, and most of those meetings involve people directly involved with or close to international "hot spots" or the seats of power. COFR is a policy-developing organization and wants very much to have a hand in shaping U.S. foreign policy. (1)

The influence of the COFR is international. In 1988, 84 non-Americans led discussion groups. Among them were: Moshe Arad, ambassador of Israel to the U.S. ; Aldofo Calero, head of the contra’s Nicaraguan Democratic Force; Kwang Soo Shoi, foreign minister of the Republic of Korea; Roberto Eisenmann, editor of La Prensa in Panama; Yotaro Kobyashi, chairman of Fuji Xerox in Japan; Carlos Tunnerman, Ambassador of Nicaragua to the U.S. ; and Han Xu, ambassador of the People’s Republic of China to the U.S. (1)

The Council co-produces a television series with City University of New York entitled "Worldview." Each show is an hour-long examination of a foreign policy issue. The first show of 1988 was an examination of the imperatives for the next president with Henry Kissinger. (1)

William Webster was the keynote speaker at COFR’s annual meeting for members and their families. (1)

Government Connections: Peter G. Peterson was Secretary of Commerce and international-economics troubleshooter in the Nixon administration. (5) He is a close friend of Henry Kissinger. Petersen is known as a "hard-as-nails" businessman. (5)

Former president of the Council, Winston Lord, was ambassador to China in the Reagan administration. (6)

William Hyland, editor of Foreign Affairs, worked under Kissinger in the Nixon administration. Before joining the administration, Hyland was the CIA’s top Kremlinologist. (5)

Peter Tarnoff was special assistant to Cyrus Vance in the State Department. (6)

Jeane Kirkpatrick and William Webster were in the Reagan administration. Webster was head of CIA and Kirkpatrick the ambassador to the United Nations. (1)

Cyrus Vance was Secretary of State in the Carter administration from 1977 to 1980. (15)

Lt. Gen. Brent Scowcroft (ret. ) was a National Security Adviser in the Ford administration from 1975 through 1977, and serves in the same capacity in the Bush administration. (15,16) From 1977 to 1980 Scowcroft served on the President’s Advisory Commissiion on Arms Control. (15)

Richard B. Cheney was a Senator from Wyoming and is currently the Secretary of Defense in the Bush administration.

Private Connections: Peter G. Peterson was the chairman of Lehman Brothers investment firm until he was ousted in a coup in 1983. (5)

Richard Cheney is co-chairman of the advisory board of the Center for strategic and International Studies. (7) Lt. Gen. Brent Scowcroft (ret. ) is an adjunct fellow at CSIS. (7)

Cyrus Vance is on the board of directors of the National Democratic Institute for International Affairs (NDI). (8) NDI was created by the Democratic Party to receive grants for "democracy building" projects from the National Endowment for Democracy. (9)

Jeane Kirkpatrick was a prominent member of the Coalition for a Democratic Majority and the Committee on the Present Danger, strongly anticommunist groups that formed in the 1970s to combat the policy of detente. (10) She is on the board of the Committee for the Free World, a group of neoconservative intellectuals who via the media undertake the defense of the noncommunist world. (11) She was also connected with the Friends of the Democratic Center in Central America (PRODEMCA), a member of the nongovernmental contra supply network. (12) Kirkpatrick is a resident scholar at the conservative think tank, the American Enterprise Institute, and is or was on the "faculty" of the CSIS. (11,13) Kirkpatrick made the keynote address and was honored with a reception at the Council for National Policy (CNP) meeting in October 1982. The CNP is an exclusive, secretive, rightwing group that envisions itself as the policymaking body of the Right. (14)

Misc: Comments: The Council on Foreign Relations is a prestigious group and membership is considered to be a plum on one’s resume. It is the oldest of the think tank establishments and over the years has been considered a moderate group. While the COFR has a large and distinguished membership, it is doubtful whether the institution itself has a significant influence on policy. There is little question, however, that many of its members have influential positions in government and do influence policy.

U.S. Address: 58 East 68th Street, New York, NY 10021.

Principals: Officers for the 1987-1988 year were: Peter G. Peterson, chair; Peter Tarnoff, pres; Warren Christopher, vice chair; John Temple Swing, exec vice pres; Lewis T. Preston, tres; Alton Frye, vice pres, Washington; William H. Gleysteen, Jr, vice pres, studies; John A. Millington, vice pres, planning and development; Margaret Osmer-McQuade, vice pres, meetings. (1)

Directors for the 1987-1988 year were: Graham T. Allison, Jr. , Harold Brown, James E. Burke, Richard B. Cheney, Warren Christopher, Robert F. Erburu, Richard L. Gelb, Alan Greenspan, Karen Elliot House, Stanley Hoffmann, B. R. Inman, Jeane J. Kirkpatrick, Juanita Kreps, Charles M. Mathias, Jr. , Donald F. McHenry, Ruben F. Mettler, Peter G. Peterson, Lewis T. Preston, William D. Rogers, Robert A. Scalapino, Brent Scowcroft, Stephen Stamas, Peter Tarnoff, Glenn E. Watts, Clifton R. Wharton, Jr. (1)

Honorary Officers and Directors Emeritii were: Arthur Dean (deceased), Douglas Dillon, George S. Franklin, Caryl P. Haskins, Joseph E. Johnson, Grayson Kirk, John J. McCloy, James A. Perkins, Philip D. Reed, David Rockefeller, Charles M. Spofford, Cyrus R. Vance. (1)

William G. Hyland is the editor of Foreign Affairs. (1)

The COFR numbers among its members many government officials from past administrations as well as the Bush administration. (1) Its membership has been noted to include individuals from the corporate world who hold overlapping corporate directorships, and therefore wield a wide base of influence in the world of commerce. The current membership also includes strong representation from the neoconservative labor community. (1)

Among the COFR members who are government officials or congresspeople from past and present administrations are: Les Aspin, James E. Baker, George W. Ball, Zbigniew Brzezinski, McGeorge Bundy, Frank C. Carlucci, Hodding Carter III, Jimmy Carter, Richard B. Cheney, William E. Colby, Sally SheltonColby, Christopher J. Dodd, Lawrence Eagleburger, Thomas Ehrlich, Dante B. Fascell, Thomas S. Foley, Gerald R. Ford, Alexander M. Haig Jr. , Richard Helms, Fred C. Ikle, Jeane J. Kirkpatrick, Henry A. Kissinger, Winston Lord, Edward N. Luttwak, Daniel P. Moynihan, Edmund S. Muskie, Paul H. Nitze, Claiborne Pell, Richard N. Perle, Richard E. Pipes, Elliot L. Richardson, John Richardson, Eugene V. Rostow, Brent Scowcroft, William E. Simon, Russell E. Train, Cyrus R. Vance, Paul A. Volcker, William Webster, Caspar W. Weinberger, and Elmo R. Zumwalt, Jr. (1)

Other notable members include: Anne Armstrong, chair of the board of the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS); conservative columnist William F. Buckley, Jr. ; neoconservative labor leaders Sol "Chick" Chaikin, Jay Lovestone, Jay Mazur, and Leo Cherne; San Antonio mayor Henry Cisneros; former CIA deputy director and current CSIS senior adviser–Ray S. Cline; editor-in-chief of the Washington Times Arnaud de Borchgrave; exec dir of the Committee for the Free World Midge Decter; secretary of the AFL-CIO William C. Doherty, Jr. ; former vice pres candidate Geraldine A. Ferraro; political scientist and former National Security Council member Samuel P. Huntington; former arms control negotiator Max M. Kampleman; CSIS dir of African studies Helen Kitchen; and prominent conservative political scientist Seymour Martin Lipset. (1)

Share RightWeb

Featured Profiles

Update was slow, but still no lag in the editor window, and footnotes are intact.     This has been updated – Bernard Lewis, who passed away in May 2018, was a renowned British-American historian of Islam and the Middle East. A former British intelligence officer, Foreign Office staffer, and Princeton University professor, Lewis was…


Bernard Lewis was a renowned historian of Islam and the Middle East who stirred controversy with his often chauvinistic attitude towards the Muslim world and his associations with high-profile neoconservatives and foreign policy hawks.


John Bolton, the controversial former U.S. ambassador to the UN and dyed-in the-wool foreign policy hawk, is President Trump’s National Security Adviser McMaster, reflecting a sharp move to the hawkish extreme by the administration.


Michael Joyce, who passed away in 2006, was once described by neoconservative guru Irving Kristol as the “godfather of modern philanthropy.”


Mike Pompeo, the Trump administration’s second secretary of state, is a long time foreign policy hawk and has led the public charge for an aggressive policy toward Iran.


Max Boot, neoconservative military historian at the Council on Foreign Relations, on Trump and Russia: “At every turn Trump is undercutting the ‘get tough on Russia’ message because he just can’t help himself, he just loves Putin too much.”


Michael Flynn is a former Trump administration National Security Advisor who was forced to step down only weeks on the job because of his controversial contacts with Russian officials before Trump took office.


For media inquiries,
email rightwebproject@gmail.com

From the Wires

Trump is not the problem. Think of him instead as a summons to address the real problem, which in a nation ostensibly of, by, and for the people is the collective responsibility of the people themselves. For Americans to shirk that responsibility further will almost surely pave the way for more Trumps — or someone worse — to come.


The United Nations has once again turn into a battleground between the United States and Iran, which are experiencing one of the darkest moments in their bilateral relations.


In many ways, Donald Trump’s bellicosity, his militarism, his hectoring cant about American exceptionalism and national greatness, his bullying of allies—all of it makes him not an opponent of neoconservatism but its apotheosis. Trump is a logical culmination of the Bush era as consolidated by Obama.


For the past few decades the vast majority of private security companies like Blackwater and DynCorp operating internationally have come from a relatively small number of countries: the United States, Great Britain and other European countries, and Russia. But that seeming monopoly is opening up to new players, like DeWe Group, China Security and Protection Group, and Huaxin Zhongan Group. What they all have in common is that they are from China.


The Trump administration’s massive sales of tanks, helicopters, and fighter aircraft are indeed a grim wonder of the modern world and never receive the attention they truly deserve. However, a potentially deadlier aspect of the U.S. weapons trade receives even less attention than the sale of big-ticket items: the export of firearms, ammunition, and related equipment.


Soon after a Saudi-led coalition strike on a bus killed 40 children on August 9, a CENTCOM spokesperson stated to Vox, “We may never know if the munition [used] was one that the U.S. sold to them.”


The West has dominated the post-war narrative with its doctrine of liberal values, arguing that not only were they right in themselves but that economic success itself depended on their application. Two developments have challenged those claims. The first was the West’s own betrayal of its principles: on too many occasions the self interest of the powerful, and disdain for the victims of collateral damage, has showed through. The second dates from more recently: the growth of Chinese capitalism owes nothing to a democratic system of government, let alone liberal values.


RightWeb
share